The Dumbledore-Severus Relationship, Was it Really Loyalty Between Them? - MuggleNet
As revealed in Snape's memories during Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, he was in love with Lily since they were young children, before. Love & relationships Albus Dumbledore, the headmaster of Hogwarts School of tower at Hogwarts at the hands of Snape may have been staged. . their sister Ariana is killed – Dumbledore, who waded in to help, is never. Lily Evans and Severus Snape as Children in Harry Potter his mother, which was a huge clue to foreshadow why he bothered to ever help the boy in the first place. . 6 Petunia Remembers Lily's Relationship With Snape.
Even as Voldemort seemed to be winning and Dumbledore passed on, Snape maintained his secrecy and devotion to the child he'd helped become a target, forgoing his own safety to ensure Harry's. Albus Dumbledore is not immune to this.
Harry, who also realized that all people make mistakes, in turn named his child after both Severus and Albus, opting to recognize their goodness. That may also be the year Lily responded favorably to James Potter's advances, perhaps after schooling him on what it meant to be a decent human being. That's a long friendship to discard after so much time invested in one another, which points to not only how seriously Snape must have taken the Dark Arts, but also how strongly Lily objected to them.
Friends typically don't give friends ultimatums, but in the case of good versus evil, we can see why Lily cut off someone who was sure to be a toxic friend at the time.
Harry Potter: 20 Crazy Revelations About Snape And Lily’s Relationship
After reading the books, it makes sense: This is the moment that saved Harry's life, where Lily chose instead to sacrifice herself to protect her infant. Hogwarts was also, as most recall, a wizarding school for adolescents who are prone to ridiculous behavior as they learn and grow. While we're meant to believe that Lily eventually knocked some sense into her future husband before marrying him, it doesn't change the fact that she married the person who bullied her best friend.
We're also reminded that Snape never apparently got over high school, becoming one of the infamous bitter teacher bullies that many of us can recall in our own youth.
Horace Slughorn, who adored Harry's mother, frequently and fondly recalled Lily's extraordinary potion-brewing abilities. Perhaps they had Potions together, as Gryffindor and Slytherin still seem to do, and maybe they even helped one another in their shared interest.
- Severus Snape
- The Dumbledore-Severus Relationship, Was it Really Loyalty Between Them?
- I’m a test widget
Should Snape be pitied? In an effort to protect him, he begins a tirade during which he belittles Harry and his father, setting Harry's back up completely and Harry feels only anger.
Snape and Dumbledore: Joint Character Analysis
Lupin steps in and takes over - lesson learned. There is a killer on the street; a man who was the cause Harry's parents were no longer alive, a death eater, a traitor. Harry has been forbidden to leave the School premises on those grounds. But does Harry listen? I think Snape is well within his rights to scold Harry and inspect an old parchment Harry has on him and one he clearly does not wish to leave with Snape.
I think Snape read that in his mind, though and he checks the paper to see if its safe and wen he sees the insults which he may have heard from the Marauders, I don't know about that, but to Snape those words make him turn to the floo and call Lupin. Snape is called upon to protect Harry specifically against Voldemort by teaching him occulmency - Snape, the adult in the sitution, allows his emotions to once again rule him and fails at enabling this particular protection.
Severus Snape | Harry Potter Wiki | FANDOM powered by Wikia
Here I think Dumbledore and Harry share the blame. Snape started well enough, but if Harry was never going to practise, because he kind of liked seeing the black door and was wanting to see what would lay beyond it, that was not going to help Occluding his mind any IMO. Snape also did not know about the scar, while I think Dumbledore had already begun suspecting.
Harry did not know why his scar hurt so much and why he could see as Nagini. Snape did not know the scar was actually a part of Voldemort.
So both of them were a bit in the dark there. Snape showed his impatience with Harry, especially as Harry kept coming out with memories of Voldemort meeting his death eaters. In fact when Harry breaks into Snape's mind, Snape is not angry nor does he shout at him. He seems shocked and surprised.
Then he proceeds to knock Harry about, taunt him and belittle his father, loses control and viciously whips Harry protection over. Buckbeak had to come in and rescue Harry from Snape himself. This is her post from the Snape's death V. This is so aptly expressed, I found it amazing.Why Lily Chose James Over Snape
An act that even Moody and Remus and Kinglesy would not agree to do for the repercussions that would follow. It is at this time Harry chases him and taunts him. Snape's mind at that time must have been terrible and yet, he merely counters Harry's curses, teaches him, shouts to the other death eaters to leave him alone until Harry calls him a coward; a coward at the time he had committed the most courageous act.
Snape hexed him and ran away. I cannot see anything wrong in this.